Jersey court may be ready to consider tax matters in future trust rulings

   0   0 Blog
Bailhache: acknowledging the unethical side of tax avoidance

Bailhache: “strong ethical arguments”

A recent judgement on an application to rectify a Jersey trust suggests that the Royal Court of Jersey may in future take account of whether a trust is being used for tax avoidance.  Remarks by the island’s Bailiff (high court judge) William Bailhache are being interpreted by some Jersey lawyers as an indication that the Court might take the tax consequences and intentions of a trust scheme into account when considering future cases.

Commenting on the case of IFM Corporate Trustees (2015 JRC 160), Bailhache noted:

“The court was initially concerned that this particular scheme might have fallen into the category of aggressive tax avoidance. . . If that were so, [it] might therefore have been the sort of scheme where in the exercise of its discretion, the court should consider whether such a fact, if true, should lead to the refusal to exercise discretion in favour of the applicant.”

In the case of IFM Corporate Trustees the Court accepted that the tax planning did not constitute unacceptable tax avoidance, but in a remark that might send shivers up the backs of tax professionals on the wilder fringe, Bailhache noted
“Historically, the courts have always applied the principles of law rather than what are perhaps inchoate and uncertain ethical considerations in this area.  What seems to us perhaps to be open to argument is whether, in an area which involves the exercise of a judicial discretion in cases where the court’s assistance is being sought for a mistake which has been made, there is room for the argument that the discretion ought not to be exercised if on the facts of a particular case, the scheme in question is lawful but appears to be so contrived and artificial that it leaves the Court with distaste if, in effect, it is required to endorse it. ”  (our emphasis added)

This remark is potentially of seismic importance, since the tax intentions of trusts have not previously been considered relevant to cases where the Jersey Court has been asked to exercise its discretion to rectify a trust.  According to one Jersey law firm, Bailhache’s remark opens the way for the Court to take account of whether or not a trust might serve as a tax avoidance vehicle:

“Potentially, any application to the court involving its discretion […] may require the tax consequences and intentions of the scheme to be aired and subjected to a wider debate whether the court should go along with them.”

Nodding in the direction of the global tax justice movement, Jersey’s Bailiff also acknowledged the ethical implications of tax avoidance, noting the

“strong ethical arguments why taxpayers should recognise their obligations to the state in which they live, making their fair and appropriate contribution towards the outgoings which any modern state has in the provision of services for the benefit of the community.”

Who could reasonably disagree with that?

Read the Royal Court judgement here

 


Related Posts

UN must defend target to curtail multinational companies’ tax abuse

Photo by Luca Santori, Creative Commons LicenseThe Tax Justice Network, The Independent Commission for the Reform of International Corporate Taxation, and the Global Alliance for Tax Justice call on the UN Secretary General to make sure the commitment to action on tax abuses by multinational companies remains part of the new UN Sustainable Development Goals.

READ MORE →

The BVI: Responsible for worldwide tax losses of $37.5 billion a year

BVI report blogAn extraordinary report by consultants Capital Economics, for BVI Finance, claims that the British Virgin Islands are responsible for $1.5 trillion of assets invested around the world, and that these result in 2.2 million jobs and $15 billion in tax revenue. A better approximation would be that the BVI imposes global tax losses of $37.5 […]

READ MORE →

Event: Making Tax Work for Women in the UK and Globally

Invitation_ Tax and Gender eventOn Wednesday 28th June 2017 at 16.30 our very own Liz Nelson will be speaking at an event in London that aims to bring together gender and tax justice advocates to highlight the need for coherent and gender-responsive fiscal policies to safeguard the rights of women and girls both in the UK and globally. The […]

READ MORE →

Historic event on women, human rights and tax justice in Bogota

BogotaLast week civil society organisations, researchers, labour union activists and policy makers met in Bogota, Colombia to explore how tax justice issues can ensure governments, multinational corporations and others meet their obligations to women in order to secure their full range of human rights. The Women’s Rights and Tax Justice conference opened with a conversation […]

READ MORE →

The Offshore Wrapper: the Panama Papers, one year on

Photos from the Protest outside PwC 1 Embankment Place, part of the Global week of action for tax justiceWelcome to the Offshore Wrapper – your weekly update from TJN.  Happy Paniversary! This week it’s been one year since the Panama Papers were leaked, and a number of organisations around the world have been marking the occasion though the global week of action for tax justice. In London, activists from the TJN and the […]

READ MORE →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top