PWC and Luxembourg: no, this wasn’t ‘legal’ behaviour

Schrodinger

Is that tax avoidance scheme legal or illegal? Until the box is opened, it’s neither

From Prem Sikka, a quote from an article from June that provides essential context for those who would dismiss the explosive leaks and analysis from the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) on Luxembourg. The Big Four accountancy firm PWC has been exposed as having facilitated and even encouraged highly abusive tax schemes, which are so extensive and outrageous that we can only refer you to the ICIJ investigation and associated stories, to grasp the seriousness of it all.

But here’s the reminder of what the UK Public Accounts Committee heard, which we referred to in our earlier blog but thought we’d pull up:

“The committee received evidence from a former senior PwC employee stating that within the firm the policy was that it would sell a tax avoidance scheme which had only a 25% chance of withstanding a legal challenge. As the committee chairperson put it “you are offering schemes to your clients – knowingly marketing these schemes – where you have judged there is a 75% risk of it then being deemed unlawful”.

There’s a crucial point here for journalists and other commentators to understand.

It is routinely asserted that these multinational ‘tax avoidance’ schemes were ‘legal’ or ‘perfectly legal’ or, worst of all, ‘perfectly legitimate.’

No. As the above quote shows, in most cases there hasn’t been a legal challenge to the scheme, so the best you can say is that the legality of this scheme is indeterminate. Their legality, Schrödinger-Cat-like, can’t be determined until they’ve been put to the test.

The point is: it is generally factually incorrect, or at least bad journalism, to assert that these schemes are ‘legal.’ We understand that these sentences are often inserted for libel reasons, but we’d argue that an the best way of dealing with a libel threat isn’t to insert an inaccuracy.

Read more about this subject here.

One other point: Luxembourg has said it has not broken any international tax rules in all this mess. Well, there are a couple of ways we’d respond to that.

First, last time we checked there was no rule-setting World Tax Authority creating rules that Luxembourg might be breaking. There is the OECD, which sets guidelines, but that’s different.

Second, more importantly, Luxembourg has made a business out of selling schemes to help multinational corporations get around international tax frameworks and national tax rules. To say it ‘hasn’t broken any international tax rules’ is a very distorted way of putting it.

Finally, we’d note that Luxembourg doesn’t just sell tax dodges. It sells secrecy – and it is a thoroughly nasty piece of work, right at the heart of the European Union.

Let’s hope these leaks cause real damage there.

 

 

 


Related Posts

UN must defend target to curtail multinational companies’ tax abuse

Photo by Luca Santori, Creative Commons LicenseThe Tax Justice Network, The Independent Commission for the Reform of International Corporate Taxation, and the Global Alliance for Tax Justice call on the UN Secretary General to make sure the commitment to action on tax abuses by multinational companies remains part of the new UN Sustainable Development Goals.

READ MORE →

The BVI: Responsible for worldwide tax losses of $37.5 billion a year

BVI report blogAn extraordinary report by consultants Capital Economics, for BVI Finance, claims that the British Virgin Islands are responsible for $1.5 trillion of assets invested around the world, and that these result in 2.2 million jobs and $15 billion in tax revenue. A better approximation would be that the BVI imposes global tax losses of $37.5 […]

READ MORE →

Event: Making Tax Work for Women in the UK and Globally

Invitation_ Tax and Gender eventOn Wednesday 28th June 2017 at 16.30 our very own Liz Nelson will be speaking at an event in London that aims to bring together gender and tax justice advocates to highlight the need for coherent and gender-responsive fiscal policies to safeguard the rights of women and girls both in the UK and globally. The […]

READ MORE →

Historic event on women, human rights and tax justice in Bogota

BogotaLast week civil society organisations, researchers, labour union activists and policy makers met in Bogota, Colombia to explore how tax justice issues can ensure governments, multinational corporations and others meet their obligations to women in order to secure their full range of human rights. The Women’s Rights and Tax Justice conference opened with a conversation […]

READ MORE →

The Offshore Wrapper: the Panama Papers, one year on

Photos from the Protest outside PwC 1 Embankment Place, part of the Global week of action for tax justiceWelcome to the Offshore Wrapper – your weekly update from TJN.  Happy Paniversary! This week it’s been one year since the Panama Papers were leaked, and a number of organisations around the world have been marking the occasion though the global week of action for tax justice. In London, activists from the TJN and the […]

READ MORE →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top