Time to investigate the Big 4 over the financial crash

Dr. Atul Shah

Dr. Atul Shah

A guest blog by Dr. Atul K. Shah, Senior Lecturer, Suffolk Business School.

As background to this, it is useful to quote from the work of Prem Sikka, cited in Shah’s research:

“Successive governments have failed to investigate the firms, or prosecute their partners. Instead, the partners of major accountancy firms are given peerages, knighthoods, public accolades and government consultancies, all funded by taxpayers. The same firms have colonised regulatory bodies, fund political parties and provide jobs for former and potential ministers. This penetration of the state has bought them political insurance and their anti-social practices continue to inflict enormous social damage.”

The time has come to investigate KPMG for audit failure at HBOS

It is well known that there was widespread audit and accounting failure in the UK prior to the 2008 Financial Crash. However, not one Big 4 audit firm has been investigated about their unqualified audits of major failed Banks prior to the Financial Crash, despite several appeals from academics like Professor Prem Sikka of Essex University, journalist Ian Fraser, author of Shredded – the truth about the RBS failure, and Richard Murphy.

This seems about to change with the latest letter from the UK Treasury Select Committee headed by Mr. Andrew Tyrie. They have asked the Financial Reporting Council to reopen its investigation into KPMG over its audit of HBOS, the biggest banking failure in British history, costing over £50 billion of public money. “It is now essential that the FRC [the UK’s Financial Reporting Council] get on with this investigation (into KPMG) without delay” – they write in a letter to the FRC CEO Stephen Hadrill. Kicking it into the long grass has been FRC’s strategy so far, but it may be that if it does so again, huge questions will be raised by the public over its own credibility as a regulator of Corporate Conduct and Accounting.

Here at Suffolk Business School, I have done detailed forensic research on the role of KPMG in the audit failure of HBOS and this paper also includes an interview with the head of Audit Quality and Ethics at KPMG. All relevant papers are linked here – and they provide rich detail. One key source for the research was the HBOS whistleblower and author Paul Moore who kept a detailed account of all his experiences and correspondence, and was also an ex-KPMG partner before he joined HBOS. Paradoxically, KPMG wrote an independent report endorsing his sacking by the HBOS CEO James Crosby, even though he was a partner there and known to the firm.

The principal findings from my research are that there were:

  • significant conflicts of interest between professional, public interest and commercial values;
  • poor ethical rules and enforcement;
  • revolving doors between KPMG, regulators and government;
  • a culture of little professional scepticism and challenge to the Board of HBOS.

Further research by me, which explores the politics of risk management at HBOS and the Regulatory Arbitrage services provided by KPMG suggest that instead of managing public risk of its audit clients, KPMG seems to give a high priority to managing its own ‘regulatory risk’ and publicly admits this. If KPMG is itself a regulator, and manages its own regulatory risk, what does all this mean for our corporate governance and accountability system for large corporates?

The problems seem to me to be much wider and systemic to the accounting profession, its ethics, conduct and regulation. Much more policing and punishment is needed of the Big 4 firms, and audit should be taken out of their control in my view as they are highly conflicted with their consultancy services. Also the ICAEW needs to discipline firmly its members involved in the HBOS fiasco. And the FRC needs a fundamental shakeup.

From Shah’s research:

Corruption of accounting

As US tax writer Francine McKenna notes:

“When it comes to the Big Four public accounting firms, the official word is still, Too Few To Fail, Too Powerful to Call to Account.”

With thanks to Atul Shah for the blog, which first appeared at Tax Research.

Related Posts

UN must defend target to curtail multinational companies’ tax abuse

Photo by Luca Santori, Creative Commons LicenseThe Tax Justice Network, The Independent Commission for the Reform of International Corporate Taxation, and the Global Alliance for Tax Justice call on the UN Secretary General to make sure the commitment to action on tax abuses by multinational companies remains part of the new UN Sustainable Development Goals.


The BVI: Responsible for worldwide tax losses of $37.5 billion a year

BVI report blogAn extraordinary report by consultants Capital Economics, for BVI Finance, claims that the British Virgin Islands are responsible for $1.5 trillion of assets invested around the world, and that these result in 2.2 million jobs and $15 billion in tax revenue. A better approximation would be that the BVI imposes global tax losses of $37.5 […]


Event: Making Tax Work for Women in the UK and Globally

Invitation_ Tax and Gender eventOn Wednesday 28th June 2017 at 16.30 our very own Liz Nelson will be speaking at an event in London that aims to bring together gender and tax justice advocates to highlight the need for coherent and gender-responsive fiscal policies to safeguard the rights of women and girls both in the UK and globally. The […]


Historic event on women, human rights and tax justice in Bogota

BogotaLast week civil society organisations, researchers, labour union activists and policy makers met in Bogota, Colombia to explore how tax justice issues can ensure governments, multinational corporations and others meet their obligations to women in order to secure their full range of human rights. The Women’s Rights and Tax Justice conference opened with a conversation […]


The Offshore Wrapper: the Panama Papers, one year on

Photos from the Protest outside PwC 1 Embankment Place, part of the Global week of action for tax justiceWelcome to the Offshore Wrapper – your weekly update from TJN.  Happy Paniversary! This week it’s been one year since the Panama Papers were leaked, and a number of organisations around the world have been marking the occasion though the global week of action for tax justice. In London, activists from the TJN and the […]


One thought on “Time to investigate the Big 4 over the financial crash

  1. Thank you very much for sharing this research. The work of TJN is a ray of hope for all of us, in a world where inequality and financial illiteracy are deliberately exploited by experts wearing the professional badge, but having few ethics and morals. They thrive on state services and infrastructure, but help their clients to avoid paying taxes. This is wrong – morally and professionally.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top