Naomi Fowler ■ European Commission to Investigate Secret #LuxLeaks Tax Deal
The European Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager has announced she is now going to investigate what we hope is the first of many secret tax deals arranged between accountancy firm PwC and the Luxembourg tax authorities. We asked recently along with Simon Bowers of the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists and John Christensen why the European Competition Commissioner, still hadn’t investigated any of the of the 546 secret tax deals exposed by the LuxLeaks whistleblowers. This, despite having launched so many other investigations into potential illegal state aid being offered to multinationals by EU member states. Simon Bowers wrote about it here and we raised the issue here.
The Luxleaks cases exposed the Luxembourg tax authorities for granting outrageously low tax rates to multi-national companies. We speculated as to whether the apparent reluctance to investigate Luxembourg’s potential role in breaking European Competition rules might be because the Competition Commissioner’s boss, the EU Commission President Jean Claude Juncker was formerly Prime Minister of Luxembourg and one of the main architects of Luxembourg’s tax haven model.
You can listen to our Taxcast Extra podcast calling for an investigation into the LuxLeaks cases here:
All this really matters – potential wrongdoing must be investigated in the public interest. Countries shouldn’t be engaged in cheating their neighbours out of tax revenue, aided and abetted by big accountancy firms like PwC. But it also matters very much to the LuxLeaks whistleblowers themselves because, as Simon Bowers says:
Luxembourg prosecutors have spent much of the last five years attempting to prosecute two Lux Leaks whistleblowers, former PwC workers Antoine Deltour and Raphael Halet, along with French journalist and ICIJ member Edouard Perrin.
Deltour and Perrin were eventually acquitted, but Halet’s case continues.
In court, prosecutors have argued Deltour and Halet were not true whistleblowers because their leaked information had failed to expose behavior that was illegal.”
The good news is, as Simon discusses here:
That assertion has now been called into question by the opening of an investigation into the Huhtamäki tax rulings”
What are the Huhtamäki tax rulings? Well, Huhtamäki is a Finnish packaging group, one of the companies which we know, thanks to the LuxLeaks whistleblowers, may have benefited from tax arrangements granted by Luxembourg that were not equally available to all companies. In a statement, the Commission now says it suspects there are three tax deals Luxembourg gave Huhtamäki offering such significant and preferential tax savings that they amounted to illegal state aid.
As Simon Bowers points out,
All Lux Leaks rulings were agreed while Jean-Claude Juncker served as prime minister of Luxembourg. He is now president of the European Commission.”
But not for much longer. It would have been a pretty poor legacy if Juncker had left the Commission without a single LuxLeaks investigation during his tenure. The questions on why that could have been allowed to happen would have continued. We’ve written extensively about Luxembourg and Juncker’s role in Luxembourg’s rapid acceleration of its tax haven model. And we were by no means alone in calling for him to go, as this Bloomberg editorial demonstrates.
And so we don’t think it’s a coincidence that it’s taken nearly five years for the European Commission to touch these cases. But the pressure was mounting, not least from our friends at the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. And there are many more Luxleaks cases to be investigated – now 545 of them…
Meanwhile, for future whistleblowers, it looks there’s been a breakthrough for EU whistleblower protection, although the German and French governments tried for a long time to block it. We’ll have a blog on that soon. As MEP Sven Giegold says,
Courageous action for the common good must enjoy the best possible legal protection”
Finally, for an idea of how damaging Luxembourg is as a tax haven, listen to why it’s currently ranked number 6 in our Financial Secrecy Index:
Argentina keeps pushing to be at the vanguard of transparency. Now they need to make more information public
How a mini movement overturned secret US shell companies
Taxing Wall Street: the Tax Justice Network December 2020 podcast
Researcher vacancies at the Tax Justice Network: Latin America and Francophone Africa
The Corporate Tax Haven Index: a Joint Research Centre audit
The State of Tax Justice 2020
20 November 2020
Submission to the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women 76th Session pertaining to the 8th periodic report submitted by Panama
15 July 2020