Now Brazil puts Ireland on its tax haven blacklist

irelandWe have for years remarked that one of our informal markers of a tax haven is loud tax haven denials. See our ‘we are not a tax haven‘ blog for more. There’s probably no place more vocal than Ireland, where there seems to be a veritable industry of tax haven deniers, which specialises in cherry-picking convenient facts and making a pudding of them. (The other big Irish tax myth is that it was the 12.5 percent corporate tax rate that created Ireland’s Celtic Tiger: no, it wasn’t.)

Let’s state it clearly: Ireland is a big tax haven for multinational corporations, even if it isn’t particularly secretive.  Or, in more succinct form, for those who have difficulty reading small text:

Ireland is a tax haven.

One example drawn from the copious outpourings of the  Irish tax haven denial industry is this 2013 paper by two Irish officials, entitled What makes a tax haven? An Assessment of International Standards Shows Why Ireland Is Not a Tax Haven. It is an especially low-grade piece of work, cherry-picking and twisting the facts to reach a pre-determined conclusion. Not the least of its problems is that it asserts at the beginning that ‘there is no agreed definition of a tax haven,’ then proceeds to try and demonstrate that Ireland isn’t one. Sigh. Yes, the most famous Irish tax trick, the Double Irish, will eventually be phased out, but there’s lots more to the Irish box of loopholes.

An even worse piece of bamboozlement, which today’s blogger was presented with in an interview on Irish Radio Newstalk this week, is cited by Ireland’s tax haven deniers all the time. There’s this claim that somehow Ireland’s tax rate for corporations is higher than France’s.

The key graph from which this factoid is drawn is this one:

ireland-v-france

And here the key take-away is from the ‘profit taxes.’ Ireland, you see, has a 12.3 percent effective profits tax rate, whereas France’s rate is 8.7 percent! Hey presto! Ireland isn’t a tax haven. We can’t emphasise enough how often we’ve seen this cited in evidence, or had this one flung at us from the deniers.

There’s just one teeny problem with this. This is just a model company, and it’s based on certain assumptions. Such as:

“Is 100% domestically owned and has five owners, all of whom are natural persons.”

This proves Ireland isn't a tax haven

That rules out Apple, Google, and all those others. But there are plenty more. Here’s another:

“Specifically, it produces ceramic flowerpots and sells them at retail. It does not participate in foreign trade (no import or export) and does not handle products subject to a special tax regime.”

(with thanks to Jim Stewart at Trinity College, Dublin, for first pointing this delicious piece of nonsense out to us: There are loads more of these assumptions: see p140 here.)

We could go on about the fact that Ireland is a tax haven.  

The U.S. Senate hearings. The EU’s recent moves against Apple‘s Irish shenanigans. Articles such as this. Our long history of how Ireland became a tax haven. Studies such as this one, containing tables like this:

ireland-usa

(By comparison, the shares for France, Germany and the UK are 0.3, 0.2 and 1.3 percent of GDP.)

Or we might cite Alex Cobham’s and Petr Jansky’s 2015 study for the International Centre for Tax and Development, which looks at the misalignment between where profits are reported, and where economic activity takes place. It concludes:

“The majority of missing profit from jurisdictions where real activity takes place ends up in just a few jurisdictions with near-zero effective tax rates – the Netherlands, Ireland, Bermuda and Luxembourg are the most important by far, and with Singapore and Switzerland account for almost the entirety of profit shifting that can be allocated to individual jurisdictions.”

And so on. Where there’s smoke, there’s fire. ‘We are not a tax haven’, indeed.

Anyway, we’ve said much of this before.

The point of this blog is really to provide a snippet of news. Brazil has just added Ireland to its list of tax havens. Ireland was added a couple of days ago.

Repeat after us:

Ireland is a tax haven.

Ireland is a tax haven.

Ireland is a tax haven.

With thanks to Juan Valerdi for the Brazil tip.

 


Related Posts

The Offshore Wrapper – Friday 18 August

panama_cityThe Offshore Wrapper is our weekly roundup of news from the world of tax justice. If you want to receive the wrapper every week in your inbox, you can subscribe here.

READ MORE →

Swiss Politicians seek to block automatic exchange of banking information with developing countries

Photo by Pedro SzekelyCould we be seeing a return to the bad old days of Swiss Banking? A right wing party in Switzerland, the Swiss People’s Party, has launched an assault on the automatic exchange of banking information, according to Swiss Daily Newspaper Tages Anzeiger.

READ MORE →

The Offshore Wrapper – Data havens and new crackdowns on tax avoidance

Gorgeous Computer FixingsBelow is the text of the offshore wrapper,  a weekly roundup of news from the world of tax justice sent out to our mailing list. If you haven’t signed up yet and would like to receive the wrapper in your inbox every week – you can do so here.

READ MORE →

Open data for tax justice – designing a new CbCR database

OD4TJlogoThis week, TJN participated in a design sprint in London organised by Open Knowledge International. The purpose of the sprint was to bring together coders and tax justice advocates to start work on building a database for the new country by country reporting data that we hope will be released in the future, if public […]

READ MORE →

New research on key role major economies play in global tax avoidance

offshore-network_colorcorrectedAn important new study on Offshore Financial Centres (OFCs) from the University of Amsterdam has made some fascinating discoveries, challenging, as the Financial Secrecy Index has, the popular misconception that tax havens are only palm fringed little islands and exposing that in fact major economies play a key role in global tax avoidance. Specifically they’ve […]

READ MORE →

About The Author

Nicholas Shaxson is a journalist and writer on the staff of Tax Justice Network. He is author of the book Poisoned Wells about the oil industry in Africa, published in 2007, and the more recent Treasure Islands: Tax havens and the Men who Stole the World, published by Random House in January 2011. He lives in Berlin
View all posts by

One thought on “Now Brazil puts Ireland on its tax haven blacklist

  1. Johnny Irish says:

    Without the Tax Haven industry Ireland would have nothing, I mean nothing, there is no homegrown employment, though the Irish hide this as they put every one on work programs and pretend its genuine jobs, but the Irish themselves are getting tired of this nonsense as the work program ‘ jobs ‘ are not considered real employment by banks, credit companies etc. The steering wheel has definitely come off the clown car otherwise known as Ireland

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top