Isabel de Saint Malo de Alvarado
Stephen Sackur and the BBC’s Hard Talk programme have been talking to Panama’s Vice President Isabel de Saint Malo de Alvarado. (It’s only available to UK-based viewers, unfortunately.)
She begins with a bout of self-congratulation about Panama, and Sackur responds with a wide number of allegations of corruption. He forces her to admit that Panama has been recalcitrant in this area.
The most pertinent section for our purposes is between around 8:30 and 13:30, where Sackur says:
“You don’t seem to have cleaned up at all . . . the Tax Justice Network has looked at your conditions and has said that you are putting up — and I don’t want to be rude — a middle finger to the OECD and that you have no real intention of changing the secrecy of your financial sector.”
Er, yes, we probably were the rude ones. What we said, on a fairly recent occasion, was that Panama’s attitude to global transparency schemes:
“is a finger (or two fingers, or a fist and forearm, depending on your cultural background) raised in the general direction of the international community and the rule of law.”
To be fair, we’re not the only people who’ve said rude things about Panama. Here’s this, for example, from a U.S. Customs official quoted in The Sink:
“The country is filled with dishonest lawyers, dishonest bankers, dishonest company formation agents and dishonest companies registered there by those dishonest lawyers so that they can deposit dirty money into their dishonest banks. The Free Trade Zone is the black hole through which Panama has become one of the filthiest money laundering sinks in the world.”
Despite the bluster from Panama, it’s hard to see how much has changed.
Off-topic, but Panamanian secrecy law is also a great shield for hackers, spammers and other computer criminals to hide behind.
not off topic at all. tax is just one aspect of the problem. interesting comment, thanks
Corporations hold capital,lots of it, that gives them Power, power to negotiate Tax laws of nations so that nations are in a race to the Tax bottom. National governments collect less tax so must cut services eventually the government cant govern effectively, the corporation takes over and the nation is a banana republic producing goods for the company at starvation wages for export to the few privileged elite rich nations. Whats amazing about this scenario is that Governments are falling over themselves to get on board with it.