The twilight of the international tax consensus

   0   0 Blog, Corporate Tax, Size of the Problem

That’s the headline of a provocative article by U.S. rock star tax expert Lee Sheppard, which states boldly in the opening column:

“Someone else’s multinationals are unfairly skipping out on their corporate tax obligations to OECD member and observer countries. That was the genesis of the OECD base erosion and profit-shifting project, which has produced an action plan that is designed to repair and preserve the fragile international consensus in the short run, but may end up upsetting it in the long run.

In the long run, the international consensus is dead, and everyone knows it, but BEPS has to be tried and allowed to fail first.”

Fiery stuff, and almost certainly correct. What will replace it?

Well, there is a long-running campaign to abolish the corporate tax altogether, based on particularly pathetic evidence and analysis – plus massive lobbying firepower. That can’t be allowed to succeed, as a first order of priority.

What is the international consensus? Sheppard answers:

It is a century old, mostly European gentlemen’s agreement to give residence countries tax jurisdiction over income earned by their residents in source countries. Legally, the source country has the superior right to tax income earned within its borders, so the consensus required countries to agree to be deprived of tax jurisdiction.

For “residence countries” read rich, OECD countries (where multinationals are resident) and for ‘source countries” read all countries where income is really earned, including developing countries. She continues:

“It has been an open secret for some time that multinationals — led by the Americans and their huge tax departments — have abused these privileges. The affected countries are no longer limited to corrupt, badly governed, resource-exporting countries. They now include European states with sophisticated tax administrations and the home governments of multinationals.

Every country is just another country to be exploited.”

We could not have said it better ourselves. And then there’s this:

“The United States and its overbanked crony, the United Kingdom, used the OECD as a vehicle to push their agendas. . . . The United States and Europe still think they run the world.”

And to cut a long story short:

“A new consensus cannot be built until the old one dies, weakened by
impossibility of administration.

In the short run, U.S. multinationals will pay some more tax to some foreign governments, but not the U.S. government. In the long run, we already know what the outcome will be — apportionment of multinationals’ profits based on sales.
. . .
The old order has to fail completely first.”

Radical stuff. Unitary taxation (profit allocation with formula apportionment) is on its way – though not just yet. We’d argue that it’s worth engaging to try and improve the OECD’s fatally flawed model, as an interim step before unitary comes. But, we think, we will see it in our lifetimes. We just need the OECD and others to accept that fact.

In fact, of course, it’s already here: lots of places are already using it, and as Prof. Picciotto notes, it’s even tacitly part of the OECD toolkit – even if their aversion to the concept is so extreme that they’d never admit it.

Update: more from Andrew Goodall on this issue just out, here.

Related Posts

The Offshore Wrapper: the Panama Papers, one year on

Photos from the Protest outside PwC 1 Embankment Place, part of the Global week of action for tax justiceWelcome to the Offshore Wrapper – your weekly update from TJN.  Happy Paniversary! This week it’s been one year since the Panama Papers were leaked, and a number of organisations around the world have been marking the occasion though the global week of action for tax justice. In London, activists from the TJN and the […]


Protesting PwC: Professionals Without Conscience

Photos from the Protest outside PwC 1 Embankment Place, part of the Global week of action for tax justiceThis week is the global week of action for tax justice and on Wednesday 5th April activists from the Tax Justice Network and Methodists for Tax Justice held a protest outside the London offices of Price Waterhouse Coopers. The global week of action for tax justice is happening one year after the release of the […]


Germany moves forward on corporate transparency

ReichstagThe Bundesrat has today voted to recommend implementing a public register of the beneficial ownership of companies and trusts.  Great news from Germany, as the country takes an important step forward towards corporate transparency.


New estimates reveal the extent of tax avoidance by multinationals

Price Waterhouse CoopersNew figures published today by the Tax Justice Network provide a country-level breakdown of the estimated tax losses to profit shifting by multinational companies. Applying a methodology developed by researchers at the International Monetary Fund to an improved dataset, the results indicate global losses of around $500 billion a year. The figures appear in a […]


Banking Secrecy in China, its related territories and Taiwan

Hong Kong from Sky 100Foreword. The Tax Justice Network is a non partisan network of experts working towards transparency, so we do not take any position about countries’ territorial and political claims. However, we do expect countries with a de jure (legal) or de facto (in practice) influence over other territories, to take responsibility for their power. We point […]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top